/tools-data567 words

Google Loses Second Round to SerpApi in DMCA Scraping Lawsuit

A court granted SerpApi's motion to dismiss Google's amended DMCA complaint over search scraping. Google must refile by November 30, 2026 or lose the case with prejudice.

Google Loses Another Round in Legal Battle Against SerpApi Over Scraping
Google Loses Another Round in Legal Battle Against SerpApi Over ScrapingPexels / pixabay
  • Judge granted SerpApi's motion to dismiss Google's amended complaint on DMCA pleading grounds
  • Google has until November 30, 2026 to file a corrected complaint or face dismissal with prejudice
  • SerpApi gets 21 days to respond to any amended filing; discovery stays on hold
  • The ruling does not decide whether SerpApi's scraping is lawful

A court has again sided with SerpApi, granting its motion to dismiss Google's amended complaint and giving Google 21 days to refile over its search-results scraping dispute. The November ruling leaves Google one more chance — until November 30, 2026 — to fix its DMCA claims or see the case dismissed with prejudice.

The judge did not rule that SerpApi's scraping practices are lawful. That point matters. The decision turns narrowly on whether Google pled sufficient factual allegations to support claims under the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA). Google's core theory in the amended complaint centered on protecting licensed content within its search results.

What is the history of the case?

Google originally sued SerpApi for scraping its search results. The court dismissed that first complaint. Google then amended the suit around licensed content in search results. SerpApi responded with a motion to dismiss the amended complaint, and the judge granted it on November grounds of insufficient factual allegations under the DMCA.

This is the second dismissal. It is a procedural victory for SerpApi, and potentially a strategically important one.

What did the judge actually decide?

The ruling addresses pleading standards, not the legality of scraping. The court is demanding a much more precise legal foundation for using the DMCA against automated scraping. Google's complaint, as filed, lacked the specificity the statute and case law require.

The next amended complaint will be the decisive document. It will show whether Google can supply the missing licensing details, copyright ownership facts, and content-specific allegations the judge identified as deficiencies.

What happens next?

The court set a defined sequence:

  • Google must correct the deficiencies identified by the judge.
  • Google must submit a redline showing changes from its previous complaint.
  • SerpApi then has 21 days to respond.
  • Discovery remains on hold while the amended complaint and any new dismissal motion are resolved.
  • If Google does not amend within the permitted period, the case will be dismissed with prejudice — ending it permanently.

The deadline for the amendment runs to November 30, 2026.

Why does this matter for the search industry?

The case tests whether the DMCA can function as an anti-scraping weapon. Search data providers, SEO tool vendors, and rank-tracking firms all depend on programmatic access to search results. A ruling forcing Google to plead precise ownership and licensing facts raises the bar for future DMCA suits against scrapers of any platform, not just Google.

For Google, the stakes cut both ways. Losing on procedure does not legitimize scraping, but repeated dismissals narrow the company's litigation options. The full ruling is available as a public PDF.

Is Google losing the scraping war elsewhere?

Not according to observable enforcement. Reports from the search community suggest Google is doing a good job blocking many scrapers through other means — technical countermeasures outside the courtroom. The X forum discussion around the case reflects that split view: legal setbacks on one track, operational friction on the other.

What should watchers monitor next?

Watch two things. First, the amended complaint Google files by November 30, 2026, specifically whether it includes concrete licensing agreements, copyright ownership chains, and named content items. Second, SerpApi's response within 21 days of filing, and whether the case survives to discovery. If Google fails to amend, dismissal with prejudice ends the suit — and leaves the DMCA's reach over automated scraping largely untested in this dispute.

via storage.courtlistener.com (Original)

More from Nathan Brooks

Nathan Brooks

Show full bio

Senior reporter covering companies, deals and strategy in Search rankings and algorithm updates, generative engine optimization at SERP Journal.

211 articles