Agencies Set Standards for Choosing AEO Platforms as AI Search Tools Multiply
VML and Omnicom executives reveal how they evaluate AEO platforms: multi-LLM coverage, data collection method, and trend tracking top the criteria list.

- Omnicom's Michael Sondak says AEO is not a lift-and-shift from 20+ years of paid and organic search practice
- Profound and Adobe Brand Visibility are the AEO platforms most cited in VML client conversations
- Multi-LLM measurement coverage and data collection method (API vs. headless browser) are top evaluation criteria
- Some AEO platforms now track brand sentiment inside LLM responses
- VML's Heather Physioc says no current metric is a definitive North Star for AI search measurement
Two of the world's largest agency holding companies are building formal evaluation frameworks for answer engine optimization platforms, as the number of AEO tools competing for brand budgets keeps growing.
Executives at VML and Omnicom told Marketing Brew that a platform's ability to measure brand visibility across multiple LLMs and its underlying data collection methodology now rank among the most decisive factors when they pick a vendor for a client. Other criteria, such as how frequently a platform refreshes its data, are weighed more strategically.
The shift is structural, not incremental. Michael Sondak, Omnicom's North America SVP and head of search, framed the change in blunt terms.
"This is not a lift-and-shift from the success that we've had for the last 20+ years in running both paid and organic search programs," Sondak told Marketing Brew. "It's wildly different: Different orchestrators, different technology, different dependents, different teams, [and] different talent."
Which AEO platforms come up most in client conversations?
VML has declined to commit to a single AEO vendor. Instead, the agency assesses each client's marketing mix and needs, then matches them to the right tool, according to Heather Physioc, VML's chief discoverability officer.
Two platforms surface most often in client discussions, Physioc said:
- Profound, in part because of its heavy marketing efforts in the category
- Adobe Brand Visibility, which can plug into some companies' existing tech stacks through platforms like Adobe Analytics
That integration advantage matters for enterprises already standardized on Adobe's analytics infrastructure, where adding a separate measurement layer would require new procurement and onboarding.
What features actually drive platform selection?
Physioc named two capabilities she focuses on first: whether an AEO platform can measure brand visibility across several LLMs, and whether it can measure trends in that data effectively over time rather than delivering point-in-time snapshots.
Beyond those basics, some platforms differentiate with less common features. Physioc cited the ability to track brand sentiment inside LLM responses as one such emerging capability.
Even so, she cautioned against treating any current metric as settled. "None of these, in my mind, are the true North Star, definitive metrics that we will always consider the extent of measuring AI search," Physioc told Marketing Brew. "I think there are more metrics to come."
Her comment signals that the measurement layer for AI search remains unsettled — agencies are buying tools today while expecting the evaluation criteria themselves to evolve.
Why does data collection methodology matter so much?
At Omnicom, internal teams scrutinize how an AEO platform actually gathers its data before recommending it, according to Dan Toplitt, Omnicom's head of AI platforms, North America.
The distinction Toplitt highlighted is technical but consequential: whether a platform collects LLM responses through an API or a headless browser. Each method carries different implications for scale, consistency and fidelity of the captured answers.
Data reliability is the second half of the equation. LLM responses to different user prompts can vary significantly, Toplitt noted, so understanding how dependable a platform's dataset is — given that inherent variability — is critical to any assessment.
What should brands and SEO teams watch next?
The agency consensus points to a market still in its evaluation phase. No vendor has emerged as a default standard, and Omnicom's own framing — that two decades of paid and organic search practice do not transfer directly — suggests procurement processes for AI visibility tools will keep maturing alongside the metrics themselves.
For brands budgeting for AEO in coming quarters, the practical checklist from agency executives is clear: multi-LLM coverage, trend measurement over time, transparent data collection methodology, and data refresh cadence, with sentiment tracking as an emerging differentiator. Watch for which platforms consolidate these capabilities — and whether a definitive North Star metric for AI search measurement finally emerges.
via Google News: generative engine optimization (Source)
More from Nathan Brooks
Show full bio
Senior reporter covering companies, deals and strategy in Search rankings and algorithm updates, generative engine optimization at SERP Journal.
228 articles